| THORBURN ASSOCIATES INC. Acoustic and Technology Consultants eNewsletter |
|||||||||||||||
| January 2005 | |||||||||||||||
In this issue:
|
|||||||||||||||
| Greetings | |||||||||||||||
| We hope this finds you well and enjoying a New Year. For us it has started out great! Steve and Eric flew out to Waco Texas to commission the Southwest Securities Financial Markets Center at Baylor University. By all accounts it is a success (see details below). As always if you have an idea, question, suggestion please drop us a note at TA@TA-Inc.com for general information or eNews@TA-Inc.com for specific comments about our eNEWSLETTER. |
|||||||||||||||
| Video Conferencing in a Box! | |||||||||||||||
| It has started again! While watching the recent football playoff and bowl games the following commercial was aired:
Two entrepreneurs are standing in an empty hanger wondering where the walls will go in their new office, when in walks a deliveryman. He hands them a phone. One of the entrepreneurs asks what it is and the deliveryman states “its your video conference room”. But it is not… While you might be able to use it as a video phone it is not a conference room! Desktop systems do not “scale”. You can probably have three or four people crowding around a monitor, but that's about it. We saw this in the late 80’s when the videoconference manufacturers were selling what they called a “roll-about”. They claimed that you could roll the unit from room to room and conference from any room. The truth was that the unit was commonly moved to one room and left there. If it was moved from room to room people frequently complained about the quality of the image and sound they experienced.In our crystal ball we are seeing the same “evolution of issues” with desktop solutions. A 500-dollar desktop system will not perform to the same level as a 10,000 to 20,000-dollar system that is properly installed and adjusted in a conference room down the hall. Lighting, background noise, camera angles, and the quality of the audio and video all affect the perceived success of a videoconference. While desktop solutions may be okay for one-to-one or one-to-few communications, they do not work well for larger groups. As always, the technology solution has to be appropriate for the intended use – one size does not fit all. |
|||||||||||||||
| Soundproof Windows? | |||||||||||||||
| It’s late at night and you’ve just settled down to sleep, when the neighborhood dog starts barking – loudly. At first you try ignoring it, then as it continues, you try covering your head with your pillow. Just as you think it might be quiet (so you can get some sleep) the other neighbor’s dog joins in! It is so loud you are convinced a train wreck just occurred in your front yard.
If this scenario or something similar plagues you or your clients, a product recently advertised on a local talk show might tempt you. One of the sponsors claims they have created “soundproof” windows that can block “over 90% of the noise”. But are they really soundproof? The problem is that as the background noise gets quieter, the same noise source – at the same level of loudness – is perceived to be louder. Going back to the barking dog example, during the day when there are lots of other noises, the dog’s barking at your cat blends with the noise from the local automobile traffic, the kids’ stereo, and the TV blaring from the house behind you. However, as night approaches all of these noise sources diminish or even go away. The background sound levels drop, and the sound of the dog barking is perceived as being much louder. So the “percentage” of noise reduction may be okay during the day, but not at night. Now back to this new wonder product. Basically what they do is provide a second “window” (i.e. a storm window) mounted a few inches inside of your existing window. While this provides a reduction in the noise levels, the same results can be achieved without using a “special” product. We recently designed a retrofit system for an office building in San Francisco. Due to the historic nature of the building, the windows could not be replaced, but the excessive traffic noise was bothering our client. A second windowpane installed inside of the window casing provided over 35 dB of field-tested noise reduction. These results were limited by the building’s background noise, but our client was very happy. As a point of reference, the following laboratory STC (Sound Transmission Class) ratings are typical for various window constructions. STC indicates the amount of noise reduction provided by an assembly – higher numbers provide better noise reduction. Field test results are usually up to 5 points below laboratory test results. Typical single pane (1/8-inch to 1/4-inch glass) window: 26-31 STC |
|||||||||||||||
| Projection Screens You Can Write On | |||||||||||||||
| In smaller conference rooms it seems like there is never enough room for the white board and the projection screen. One option is to use the white board as the projection surface. While a white board that can be projected on may be just the solution you are looking for, there are some limitations. The typical material used for white boards is either melamine or porcelain. When an image is projected onto a these surfaces, there is a definite “hot spot” or glare that makes viewing by the audience difficult, or unpleasant for lengthy meetings or classes.
A number of companies have developed wall coverings that can be used as both a white board and as a projection surface. These products are typically applied over primed drywall and can provide wall-to-wall and floor-to-ceiling coverage, similar to any other wall-covering product. They combine the features of a projection screen (wide angle viewing, reduced glare, reduced image fall-off) with a dry erase surface. In the right situation, and when used with solvent-based dry erase markers, these products work well. That being said, we do not recommend these products for large rooms because the impact of handwritten notes on a properly sized image is usually ineffective. In many situations the projected image is so large that for someone to “fill in the blank” of a sentence or math problem they would be trying to draw foot-tall letters or numbers. In smaller rooms this becomes less of an issue. To protect the longevity of any projection white board surface, using solvent-based dry erase markers (like Sanford’s Expo 1 series) will help reduce the residual build up seen from wax-based dry erase markers (like Sanford’s Expo 2 series). |
|||||||||||||||
| Baylor University – Southwest Securities Financial Markets Center | |||||||||||||||
| Baylor University officially dedicated the Southwest Securities Financial Markets Center, a world-class investment facility in the Hankamer School of Business, during a ceremony January 12 on the Baylor campus. Baylor’s newest classroom is a remodeled space in the Hankamer School of Business building. The Center is the brainchild of Dr. Terry Maness, dean of the Business School.
The Center will allow graduate students and senior finance majors hands-on learning in the truest sense of the word as they manage one of the largest student-run portfolios in the nation - currently worth $6 million - from the new facility. Thorburn Associates’ involvement with the project began in meeting with Dean Maness and other faculty members to define the goals of the project. We really had a blank slate to work with. One objective was to create a room that felt like a cross between a financial boardroom and a trading room. Another goal was to create a grand entrance to the space, which was accomplished by removing a non-load baring CMU wall and extending the entrance into an existing storeroom. Once Thorburn Associates developed the basic design of the space, we worked with the campus architect to refine and execute the project. This was a great example of the AV function driving the form of the room. We are pleased to be a part of this fantastic project! More information and photos can be found at: http://pr.baylor.edu/story.php?id=005574 |
|||||||||||||||
| Standards On-line and Up-to-Date | |||||||||||||||
| While attending the California Council Desert Practice Conference in October we had the chance to talk with David Richards of IHS Engineering. IHS is the world's largest distributor of technical standards, codes, specifications, and related documents. Their Standards Store allows you to search and purchase individual documents from more than 450 technical societies around the world such as AIA/NAS, ANSI, API, ASQ, ASME, ASTM, AWS, BSI, CSA, DIN, EIA, GM, IEC, ICEA, IEEE, IPC, ISA, ISO, NEMA, NFPA, SAE, TIA UL to name a few. Collections are also available by subscription, including British Standards. Delivery Methods for IHS standards include over the web, CD-ROM, and others. So what this means, is that for a fee you can keep your office up to date on all types of standards that might be needed in the design and engineering of your next project. While the fee is not small in many cases it will be more cost effective than ordering the paper versions of the standards every time they are updated. More information can be found at www.ihs.com. Copyright 2005 |
|||||||||||||||
THANK YOU FOR READING OUR eNEWSLETTER TA now publishes an eNewsletter once every two months. We are always looking for new topics and ideas. Please drop us a note at eNews@TA-Inc.com with any comments or suggestions. STAY SUBSCRIBEDIf you change your e-mail address, remember to re-subscribe – just follow this link: Feel free to pass this eNewsletter on to your friends and colleagues. If you are getting this second hand and want your own copy – just follow the link above. Feel free to quote any part of this newsletter; just give us credit and let us know how and where the quote will be used. TO UNSUBSCRIBE THORBURN ASSOCIATES INC.
|
|||||||||||||||